Engaging Millennial Donors: Strategies to Connect with a Socially Conscious Generation
Millennials, born between 1981 and 1996, have grown into an influential and distinct generation. Having experienced pivotal events like the 9/11 attacks, the 2008 recession, and the rise of the internet, Millennials bring unique perspectives and expectations to philanthropy.
In 2024, Millennials are between 28 and 43 years old. As their influence and purchasing power continue to grow, they’re becoming an increasingly vital demographic for nonprofits. This generation is socially conscious, highly educated, and committed to making a difference – but they don’t engage with causes in the same way as older generations.
Overlooking this cohort in your fundraising and marketing efforts could mean missing out on the long-term support of loyal advocates. So, how can your nonprofit secure Millennial support?
The short answer: Adapt your approach to fundraising, communication, and engagement to suit Millennials’ values, lifestyle, and philanthropic behavior.
If you’re looking for the long answer, keep reading! In this article, I draw on peer-reviewed research about Millennials’ values, experiences, and unique approach to philanthropy. Once you understand what motivates this cohort and how they prefer to connect with your cause, you’ll be much better positioned to build lasting relationships that inspire their ongoing support.
So, let’s dive in! Here’s what you need to know about Millennial donors and how to engage them effectively.
Debunking the Stereotypes: What Your Need to Know About Millennials in Philanthropy
Millennials are often mischaracterized as self-centered, disengaged, and stingy. Additionally, while many Millennials remember life before widespread internet use, older generations often perceive them as socially impaired due to their reliance on the internet.
However, this couldn’t be further from the truth. Though their financial realities may impact their philanthropic habits, Millennials – driven by a deep understanding of inequality and a desire to make a difference – are among the most socially aware and altruistic generations in your donor database.
Let’s explore how Millennial philanthropy compares to that of older generations and why it’s crucial to nurture these relationships, even if their gifts seem smaller at first.
Millennials donate less often but give proportionally more. While Millennials may donate less frequently than older generations, the percentage of their income they contribute is often higher. This shows that Millennials are deeply invested in the causes they support, even though they may not have the financial resources of their parents. Focus on building relationships with Millennial donors now, as their capacity to give will likely grow over time.
Wealth correlates with giving, but Millennials aren’t the wealthiest generation (yet). Wealthier Millennials are more likely to donate, just like previous generations. However, this cohort as a whole have faced economic challenges, including the 2008 recession, which delayed wealth accumulation. Keep in mind that as this generation inherits wealth, their ability to give will increase, which means you should start focusing on engaging and building relationships with Millennials now. One way to do this is by offering volunteer opportunities; according to Nittany Lion Consulting Group (NLCG), 70% of Millennials say they prefer volunteering to donating.
Certain demographic conventions correlate with giving, but Millennials have broken the mold. Marriage, employment, education, and religious affiliation all positively correlate with charitable giving, as they do with older generations. Millennials have achieved higher levels of education than their predecessors, and although they’re less likely to be married or affiliated with organized religion, those who are tend to give more. Nonprofits should target outreach to employed, married Millennials while also recognizing the potential of those not yet in these life stages.
Optimize Your Online Presence for Discerning and Tech-Savvy Donors
Millennials have grown up in a world where technology is at the center of communication, work, and even charitable giving. They are well-versed in navigating the digital space, using social media to stay informed and websites to research causes they care about. For nonprofits, meeting Millennials where they spend a large chunk of their time – online – is can help you build relationships and motivate support.
Here are some tips for creating an engaging online presence that resonates with this tech-savvy generation:
Use social media strategically. Social media is to Millennials what community bulletin boards were to Boomers. Millennials spend a significant portion of their day interacting with friends, family, and content on sites like Facebook, Instagram, and X. Like bulletin boards, social media sites offer a space for discovering causes, sharing opportunities, and fostering local connections – key elements of nonprofit outreach. Posting real-time updates, behind-the-scenes content, and impactful visuals helps build a sense of community and keeps Millennials interested and engaged.
Engage your future donors!
Share content that makes an impact.
Update your website. According to NLCG’s report, Millennials do substantial research before making a donation to ensure their money will make an impact. With Millennials’ tendency to quickly abandon slow or cluttered websites, your nonprofit must ensure your web presence is seamless and informative. A user-friendly website that is mobile-responsive, easy to navigate, and provides detailed information on your mission, goals, and success stories can influence their decision to give.
Simplify your donation processes. Make it easy to donate on your website, and you’ll likely increase follow-through from Millennials. Offer preset donation amounts that show the impact of each contribution, and include options for digital wallet payments like PayPal or Apple Pay. While direct mail is still effective, Millennials are less likely to use traditional reply forms. Instead, modernize your donation slips with QR codes to let your younger supporters donate quickly with just a few taps on their phones.
Build Genuine Relationships with Millennial Donors
Relationship-building is key to maintaining any donor’s loyalty over time, but it’s especially effective when it comes to retaining Millennials’ support as this cohort is especially relationship-oriented in the context of charitable giving. Here’s how to foster fruitful and genuine relationships with Millennials to earn their trust and inspire long-term commitment from this generation:
Build one-on-one relationships with Millennial donors. Millennials enjoy smaller social circles than older generations, and they value individual attention and personalized communication. Assign a team member to manage and build relationships with individual Millennial donors. Regularly check in, share updates, and show appreciation for their support. A personal connection can increase a Millennial’s commitment to your nonprofit and make them feel valued as more than just a donor.
Create a sense of a tight-knit community. Millennials form very close and tight-knit relationships within their smaller social groups. Create opportunities for this cohort to engage with your organization and other like-minded supporters by hosting virtual meet-ups, peer-to-peer fundraising events, or online discussions about your cause. Like most generations, Millennials are more likely to stay engaged when they feel like they are part of a community.
Embody the leadership traits Millennials value. Millennials are drawn to leaders who are dedicated, open-minded, culturally sensitive, and ethical. They seek leaders who inspire them and lead by example – those who are hardworking, transparent, and willing to roll up their sleeves to work alongside their teams. Reflect these leadership qualities in your organization’s culture and communication to build stronger, trust-based relationships with your Millennial donors.
Be transparent and authentic. Millennials are keen to support organizations that demonstrate authenticity and transparency in their operations and communication. They want to know exactly where their donations are going and the impact they are making. Provide regular updates with clear metrics, success stories, and infographics that show how their contributions help. When you foster transparency, you build trust and long-term relationships.
Collaborate with Millennial-Friendly Businesses
Many Millennials value corporate social responsibility (CSR) and believe that businesses should play a larger role in addressing societal issues. So, what does Millennials’ relationship with the for-profit sector have to do with your nonprofit?
You can use it to your advantage by collaborating with companies that resonate with this generation’s ideals. Your nonprofit can benefit from positive publicity and increased support:
Co-host events and activities with relevant businesses. Partnering with Millennial-friendly businesses can attract new donors and broaden your nonprofit’s reach, while also demonstrating the business’s commitment to corporate social responsibility (CSR). For example, let’s say your nonprofit provides meals to people experiencing homelessness. Local restaurants might like to contribute ingredients. This win-win situation offers both the restaurant and your organization valuable publicity (e.g., the restaurant might make a social media post that says, “we teamed up with Local Nonprofit to serve 50 warm meals this weekend”).
Launch “round-up for charity” programs. Many businesses have embraced the idea of “rounding up” customer purchases to the nearest dollar, with the difference going to charity. Partner with companies to implement such programs, encouraging Millennials to make micro-donations as part of their routine. These small, consistent donations can accumulate over time and make a significant impact.
Discount cards and rewards programs. Millennials love a good deal (who doesn’t?), and many are drawn to charitable initiatives that come with added incentives. Collaborate with businesses to offer discount cards or rewards programs where a percentage of the sale goes to your nonprofit. This gives Millennials the chance to support your cause while enjoying savings.
Leverage Peer-to-Peer Strategies
With a strong presence on social media, Millennials are excellent vehicles for word-of-mouth marketing. They are both highly influential and highly influenced by their peers, making peer-to-peer fundraising a highly effective strategy for engaging this generation. Millennials trust recommendations from people they know, which makes these initiatives powerful tools for nonprofits.
Coordinate peer-to-peer campaigns. Peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns often generate more donations because of the personal connection involved. However, your nonprofit should take on an active role in this system by providing your supporters with materials, such as personalized donation pages and engaging content, to share with their social networks.
Support your fundraisers. While Millennials may be enthusiastic fundraisers, they need your nonprofit’s support to be successful. Offer them guidance, storytelling tips, and branded materials they can share with their networks. This kind of guidance can inspire your fundraisers to feel more confident about promoting your cause and attracting more donations.
Create effective badges for donors to share on social media. Badges, banners, and shareable images for people to share on social media after donating can help propel engagement, visibility, and additional support. Keep in mind that this is one instance where your messaging can (and should) focus on your organization’s mission rather than the donor. For example, instead of a generic “I donated” badge, create one that emphasizes the impact of their support, like “Join me and Animal Humane in providing life-saving care to animals.”
Conclusion
Go beyond the trends and challenge yourself to truly understand Millennials’ circumstances and values. Tap into their desire to make a difference by building real relationships, enhancing digital touchpoints, and partnering with businesses that reflect their ideals. When you prioritize stewardship and transparency, you create the trust and authenticity needed to turn Millennial donors into lifelong supporters and advocates for your cause.
Make a bigger impact.
I offer on-call fundraising & marketing support for nonprofits.
-
Andrade, E., McKeever, A. J., Rivera, R., Withers, E., & Woo, H. (2020). Millennials and Moral Panic in the United States and beyond. Sociological Perspectives, 63(3), 496–505. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/0731121420919590.
Boman, L., & He, X. (2024). EXPRESS: Sharing to Persuade: the Role of Donor- versus Charity-Focused WOM. Journal of Marketing Research. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/00222437241268491.
Dalessandro, C. (2018). Recruitment Tools for Reaching Millennials. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 17(1), 160940691877444. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406918774446.
Fry, R. (2024, April 26). How Millennials today compare with their grandparents 50 years ago. Pew Research Center. Retrieved from https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/03/16/how-millennials-compare-with-their-grandparents/.
Hartman, J. L., & McCambridge, J. (2011). Optimizing Millennials’ Communication Styles. Business Communication Quarterly, 74(1), 22–44. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/1080569910395564.
Koczanski, P., & Rosen, H. S. (2019). Are Millennials Really Particularly Selfish? Preliminary Evidence From a Cross-Sectional Sample in the Philanthropy Panel Study. American Behavioral Scientist, 63(14), 1965–1982. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219850871.
Kumbla, P. K. (2020). From Commitment to Passion: Appraising the Energy of Millennials. NHRD Network Journal, 13(4), 416–423. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/2631454120951877.
Mahapatra, G. P., Bhullar, N., & Gupta, P. (2022). Gen Z: An Emerging Phenomenon. NHRD Network Journal, 15(2), 246–256. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/26314541221077137.
Omilion-Hodges, L. M., & Sugg, C. E. (2018). Millennials’ Views and Expectations Regarding the Communicative and Relational Behaviors of Leaders: Exploring Young Adults’ Talk About Work. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly, 82(1), 74–100. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/2329490618808043.
The Modern Nonprofit: Strategic Shifts to Engage Gen Z and Millennial Donors | Nittany Lion Consulting Group. (2021, December 9). Nittany Lion Consulting Group. Retrieved from https://nlcgpsu.org/the-modern-nonprofit-strategic-shifts-to-engage-gen-z-and-millennial-donors/.
